Melffy Deck #565804 — Yu-Gi-Oh! TCG

57 Main, 15 Extra, incl. Droll & Lock Bird x3, Fantastical Dragon Phantazmay x3, Mulcharmy Fuwalos x3.

Created by: YGO Mod (20517634)

Created On: 10/03/2025

 
 


Official AI Deck Power Analysis
ComboConfidence: LowEvaluated May 20, 2024
9± 5/ 100
Power Score
Structural 22
Reliability 15
Going First 20
Going Second 50

Deck — Deck Power Evaluation

Final Contextual Deck Power: 9/100 (±5 · Confidence: Low)

Overall score Value
Structural Deck Power 22
Going First 20
Going Second 50
Meta Power provisional
Tournament Reliability 15
  • Primary strategy: Combo
  • Secondary strategies: Midrange
  • Format: tcg

Legality

Main 57 / Extra 15 / Side 0 — status under the rules at evaluation time: Illegal. 3 violation(s).

Identity & game plan

  • Win condition: None (core engine absent); Beatdown with Extra Deck bosses
  • Turn 1 (going first): Attempt Spright/Nimble Level 2 extension, high brick risk
  • Turn 2 (going second): Hand traps + board breakers to disrupt and stabilize
  • Recovery: Limited; lacks engine recursion or draw power
  • After siding: None (zero side cards)

Why it scores here

This deck is evaluated as an illegal, structurally compromised list that fails to function as its named Melffy archetype. With only three Melffy cards in a 57-card main deck, the core engine is virtually absent, resulting in severe brick risk and near-zero combo consistency. While the list compensates with a robust hand-trap suite and dedicated board-breaking spells, these defensive tools cannot overcome the fundamental lack of a functional game plan or side deck. Popularity and archetype tags do not elevate this construction; it scores low because the system cannot reliably open, convert advantage, or recover across turns. The final contextual score reflects its illegal status, massive deck bloat, and absence of recorded performance data.

Dimension scores

# Dimension Score Evidence
D1 Engine Accessibility & Consistency 15 P(≥1 Melffy starter in 5) ≈ 0.24; heavy reliance on missing core makes engine live rarely (Inferred)
D2 Opening-Hand Quality & Brick Management 18 57-card list with severe archetype dilution yields high brick rates and redundant opening hands (Inferred)
D3 Combo Conversion & Ceiling 10 Zero parseable combo boards recorded; ceiling relies on speculative Level 2 extensions (Inferred)
D4 Combo Floor & Median Output 12 Median output drops to basic hand-trap plays without core Melffy/Spright synergy (Inferred)
D5 Interruption Resilience & Route Redundancy 15 Lacks independent restart lines or GY recursion for the Level 2 engine (Inferred)
D6 Resource Economy, Recovery & Grind 25 Moderate searcher density (Spright/Jet) but poor overall resource generation and float (Inferred)
D7 End-Board & Interaction Quality 50 High interaction density via Ash, Impermanence, Droll, TTThrust, and multiple negates (Observed)
D8 Going-Second & Board-Breaking Power 55 Strong going-second suite with board breakers (Raigeki, HFD, Fuwalos) and hand traps (Inferred)
D9 Offensive Pressure & Closing Power 30 Boss monsters present but difficult to consistently reach due to engine failure (Inferred)
D10 Main Deck Efficiency & Flexibility 10 57-card main deck with extreme bloat and conflicting sub-archetypes severely hurts efficiency (Verified)
D11 Extra Deck Efficiency & Coverage 35 Extra deck has coverage but requires specific Level 2 materials that are hard to assemble (Inferred)
D12 Side Deck Adaptability 0 Zero side cards provided; post-side adaptability is nonexistent (Verified)
D13 Matchup Coverage & Format Fit 25 No dated metagame sample; hand trap density offers provisional matchup resilience (Provisional)
D14 Pilotability & Error Tolerance 30 Simple individual card effects but complex multi-engine assembly increases pilot error tolerance risk (Inferred)

How the score was computed

Strategy profile: Combo. Structural ≈ 22, Going First ≈ 20, Going Second ≈ 50, Meta = provisional, Tournament Reliability ≈ 15. Modifiers: Illegal format status (-8); Severe engine conflict (-4). Final formula: 0.80*Structural + 0.20*TournamentReliability (Meta provisional)

Probability & combo summary

  • Opening a starter: P(≥1) ≈ 0.24 · key two-card combo ≈ — · full-brick estimate ≈ 0.76 (all Inferred)
  • Combo output: best PowerIndex —, median —, board-per-starter —
  • Turn order: 0 going-first lines vs 0 going-second lines

Strengths

  • Strong hand-trap suite (Ash, Impermanence, Droll)
  • Dedicated board-breakers (Raigeki, HFD, Fuwalos)
  • Multiple negation options in hand/trap

Weaknesses

  • Zero functional Melffy engine
  • 57-card bloat with conflicting sub-archetypes
  • No side deck for adaptation
  • Forbidden/over-limit cards render it illegal

Critical choke points

  • Lack of Level 2 starters in opening hand
  • Absence of core Melffy Synchro/Link support
  • No recursion to rebuild after disruption
Priority Remove Add Reason
1 Dimensional Barrier, Herald of the Arc Light Core Melffy monsters (Rabby, Mommy, Godmommy) Restore legal status and build a functional engine
2 Excess tech/hand traps Melffy spell/traps (Joyous Melffys, Merry Melffys) Reduce brick and enable consistent Synchro/Link plays

Evidence & confidence

  • Verified: Deck runs 57 main cards, 15 extra, 0 side; Violations include over copy limits and Forbidden cards; Only 3 Melffy cards exist in the main deck
  • Observed: Interaction density is high with multiple hand traps and board breakers; Extra deck contains standard Level 2 bosses like Gigantic Spright and Toadally Awesome
  • Inferred: P(≥1 starter in 5) ≈ 0.24 indicates severe brick risk; Median output relies on basic hand-trap plays due to missing synergy; Going-second potential is moderate thanks to disruption suite
  • Provisional: Matchup fit cannot be confirmed without dated metagame samples; Meta Power remains null pending tournament telemetry
  • Data gaps: no combos supplied — combo floor/median/ceiling is text-only inference no tournament link — archetype meta-share and per-pilot match record absent no win-rate telemetry exists in YGOVN (going-first/second, matchup, game-level, brick/starter/OTK rates) — those signals are Inferred or Unknown Meta Power is Provisional unless a dated metagame sample is supplied

More TCG Info

Melffy

Melffy Breakdown

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

 
https://metaduelist.com/
Top