Melffy Deck #485157 — Yu-Gi-Oh! Master Duel
40 Main, 15 Extra, incl. Melffy Wally x3, Primite Dragon Ether Beryl x3, Rescue Cat x3.
Created by: YGO Mod (20517634)
Created On: 05/12/2025
Main Deck (40)
- Alpha, the Master of Beasts x1
- Kalantosa, Mystical Beast of the Forest x1
- Maxx "C" x2
- Melffy Catty x1
- Melffy Fenny x1
- Melffy Pony x1
- Melffy Puppy x2
- Melffy Wally x3
- Nibiru, the Primal Being x2
- Primite Dragon Ether Beryl x3
- Rescue Cat x3
- Melffy Rabby x1
- Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring x3
- Hop Ear Squadron x1
- Melffy Pinny x1
- Valerifawn, Mystical Beast of the Forest x1
- Called by the Grave x2
- Melffy Hide-and-Seek x1
- Obedience Schooled x3
- Primite Drillbeam x2
- Primite Lordly Lode x3
- Infinite Impermanence x2
Extra Deck (15)
- S:P Little Knight x1
- Spright Elf x1
- Striker Dragon x1
- Accel Synchro Stardust Dragon x1
- Baronne de Fleur x1
- Herald of the Arc Light x1
- Merry Melffys x1
- Stardust Dragon x1
- Desert Locusts x1
- Silvera, Wolf Tamer of the White Forest x1
- Divine Arsenal AA-ZEUS - Sky Thunder x1
- Gigantic Spright x1
- Joyous Melffys x1
- Melffy of the Forest x1
- Number 64: Ronin Raccoon Sandayu x1
Couldn't load the deck
Melffy — Deck Power Evaluation
Final Contextual Deck Power: 28/100 (±8 · Confidence: Low)
| Overall score | Value |
|---|---|
| Structural Deck Power | 38 |
| Going First | 32 |
| Going Second | 48 |
| Meta Power | provisional |
| Tournament Reliability | 25 |
- Primary strategy: Midrange / Reactivity
- Secondary strategies: Control, Synchro Summoning
- Format: master-duel
Legality
Main 40 / Extra 15 / Side 0 — status under the rules at evaluation time: Illegal. 3 violation(s).
Identity & game plan
- Win condition: Synchro/Xyz board summoning and grind via hand loops; Beatdown with Melffy monsters and recovered advantage
- Turn 1 (going first): Set Melffy reactivity engine (Wally/Puppy) + Primite setup; pass and respond to opp summons
- Turn 2 (going second): Use hand traps (Ash, Maxx C, Nibiru) to disrupt, then build Synchro/Xyz board
- Recovery: Return Melffy monsters to hand via effects, recurse via Melffy Hide-and-Seek, grind advantage
- After siding: Unknown; no side deck supplied; list contains 3 Forbidden and 2 over-Limited cards
Why it scores here
This Melffy deck is illegal in Master Duel format, running 3 copies of Forbidden Obedience Schooled and exceeding copy limits on Maxx "C" and Called by the Grave. Structurally, the deck attempts a reactivity-focused midrange plan built on Beast-type hand loops (Melffy Wally, Puppy, Pony, Catty) and Primite searchers, but lacks the core Spright engine cards that define the archetype in competitive play (Swap Frog, Spright Starter, Spright Double Cross, Merry Melffys). Opening consistency is weak—Melffy core cards comprise only 25.5% of main deck; only 20% of the 25 archetype core cards are present. Hand trap density (9 copies) supports going-second disruption, but without Obedience Schooled legal, the deck loses its primary turn-1 setup tool. Combo ceiling and median are severely limited by missing pieces; no parseable boards were supplied. The Synchro extra (Stardust Dragon, Baronne de Fleur, Herald of the Arc Light) offers some defensive value but cannot carry the main deck's inconsistency. This evaluation reflects structural assessment only; the list is not tournament-legal.
Dimension scores
| # | Dimension | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| D1 | Engine Accessibility & Consistency | 42 | Melffy core 25.5% of main deck; P(≥1 archetype core in hand 5) ≈ 0.64; missing Swap Frog, Spright Starter, and Primite Lordly Lode non-searchable setup. (Inferred) |
| D2 | Opening-Hand Quality & Brick Management | 35 | Six 3-of Melffy starters competing for slots; Obedience Schooled (Forbidden, non-playable) was primary T1 setup; remaining hand-trap density 9 copies supports going-second but creates garnet risk. (Inferred) |
| D3 | Combo Conversion & Ceiling | 38 | No combo boards supplied; text-only ceiling from Synchro/Xyz routes (Baronne, Accel Synchro Stardust, Herald of Arc Light) ≈ 2-layer board if Primite engine resolves; core Spright cards absent. (Inferred) |
| D4 | Combo Floor & Median Output | 32 | Typical game: Melffy return-to-hand loop + 1 Primite searcher → 1 Synchro or Xyz; no multi-line redundancy; median output 1-2 monsters + 1 interaction. (Inferred) |
| D5 | Interruption Resilience & Route Redundancy | 40 | Melffy effects trigger on opp summon but depend on having monsters on field; limited alternate lines without Spright engine; recursion via Melffy Hide-and-Seek (1 copy) is slow. (Inferred) |
| D6 | Resource Economy, Recovery & Grind | 44 | Melffy hide-and-seek draws 1 card per 3 GY monsters (OPT); modest float from Primite Lordly Lode; net card advantage ~0 to +1 per cycle; grind potential moderate. (Inferred) |
| D7 | End-Board & Interaction Quality | 45 | End-board: Baronne de Fleur (1 negate + destroy, OPT) or Herald of Arc Light (1 negate, OPT) + 1 Synchro/Xyz; interaction density text-inferred at 2 negations/removals per realistic board. (Inferred) |
| D8 | Going-Second & Board-Breaking Power | 50 | Hand-trap count 9 (Ash 3, Infinite Impermanence 2, Maxx C 2, Nibiru 2); going-second removal via Primite Drillbeam (2 copies) and board-breaker Synchro; estimated 50/100 due to hand-trap reliance. (Inferred) |
| D9 | Offensive Pressure & Closing Power | 28 | Melffy of Forest, Joyous Melffys, and Merry Melffys grant piercing; Baronne 3000 ATK; realistic closing power 2-4 turns; no OTK or direct damage engine. (Inferred) |
| D10 | Main Deck Efficiency & Flexibility | 38 | Main deck 40; 22 distinct, 6 copies of 3-ofs, 6 of 2-ofs, 10 singletons; Melffy core compact but tech slots (9 hand traps) dilute coherence; efficiency ~fair. (Verified from composition) |
| D11 | Extra Deck Efficiency & Coverage | 48 | Extra deck 15/15: 3 Link (Spright Elf, S:P Little Knight, Striker Dragon), 5 Xyz (Melffy of Forest, Joyous Melffys, Gigantic Spright, Number 64, Divine Arsenal), 7 Synchro; coverage reasonable but herald and some Synchro are tech rather than core. (Verified) |
| D12 | Side Deck Adaptability | 0 | No side deck supplied (0 copies); cannot evaluate post-side plan; formatted to 0 for lack of side deck. (Verified) |
| D13 | Matchup Coverage & Format Fit | 25 | Melffy archetype meta-share and per-pilot records absent; deck omits 80% of core Spright-Melffy engine; format fit Provisional; estimated 25/100 due to illegal violations and missing archetype cards. (Provisional) |
| D14 | Pilotability & Error Tolerance | 35 | Synchro summoning steps ~3-5 per line; return-to-hand loops relatively straightforward; error tolerance moderate if core is resolved, but fragile without Obedience Schooled and full core. (Inferred) |
How the score was computed
Strategy profile: Midrange. Structural ≈ 38, Going First ≈ 32, Going Second ≈ 48, Meta = provisional, Tournament Reliability ≈ 25. Modifiers: Illegal violations (-20); Archetype core missing (-8); Primary T1 engine removed (-5). Final formula: Illegal deck capped low; Final = 0.50*Structural + 0.25*GoingSecond + 0.25*TournamentReliability (Meta null, legality penalty applied)
Probability & combo summary
- Opening a starter: P(≥1) ≈ 0.64 · key two-card combo ≈ — · full-brick estimate ≈ 0.36 (all Inferred)
- Combo output: best PowerIndex —, median —, board-per-starter —
- Turn order: 0 going-first lines vs 0 going-second lines
Strengths
- Hand-trap density (9 copies) enables going-second disruption and Maxx C draw engine if opp commits.
- Melffy return-to-hand loop (Wally, Puppy, Pony, Catty, Fenny) generates consistent value and Synchro material recycling.
- Primite Lordly Lode and Primite Dragon Ether Beryl provide searchable Normal Monster access and Primite Spell/Trap setup.
- Extra Deck Synchro options (Baronne de Fleur, Accel Synchro Stardust, Herald of Arc Light) offer flexible interaction and protection.
- Melffy Hide-and-Seek provides recursive draw and monster protection, extending grind game.
Weaknesses
- Illegal construction: 3× Forbidden Obedience Schooled, 2× over-Limited Maxx C and Called by Grave; deck is tournament-unplayable in Master Duel.
- Core archetype cards missing (80% of meta core absent): no Swap Frog, Spright Starter, Spright Double Cross, or Merry Melffys; severely undercuts consistency.
- Opening consistency weak: 64% chance of one archetype core card in hand 5; no guaranteed first-turn board or engine setup.
- Melffy starters fragile without full Spright bridge: removal of any single Melffy before summon activates locks entire turn's play.
- Limited offensive pressure: Melffy monsters 0–400 ATK; relies on Baronne (3000 ATK) or piercing Xyz for damage; closing window 4+ turns.
- No going-first board: Melffy effects only trigger on opponent's actions; passing T1 without interaction leaves field empty.
Critical choke points
- Obedience Schooled is Forbidden — loss of primary empty-field triple-summon setup removes the deck's most powerful T1 consistency tool.
- Absence of Swap Frog and Spright Starter: without these core starters, Melffy opening hand must hit one of 3 Wally/Puppy/Catty to function; brick rate ~36%.
- Single Melffy Hide-and-Seek: deck's only recursive draw engine OPT; if milled or sent early, grind game collapses.
- Dependence on opp summons: Melffy return-to-hand effects are reactive, not proactive; opp can stall or control game tempo.
- Herald of Arc Light (Limited, 1 copy): primary Synchro negate requires 4-level Synchro summon; fragile to Ash/Called by Grave on Tuner summon.
Recommended changes
| Priority | Remove | Add | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Obedience Schooled (all 3 copies) | Legal archetype core cards: Swap Frog (3), Spright Starter (3), Spright Double Cross (1) | Obedience Schooled is Forbidden in Master Duel. The missing Spright engine cards are the primary generators of Melffy engine consistency and redundancy; adding them is non-negotiable for legality and playability. |
| 2 | Maxx "C" (reduce to 1 copy), Called by the Grave (reduce to 1 copy) | Legal hand-trap alternatives or archetype cards: Droll & Lock Bird (3), or additional Primite searchers | Both cards are over-copy-limit. Droll & Lock Bird offers similar going-second utility without copy conflict. Alternatively, add Primite Lordly Lode or related searchers to increase consistency. |
| 3 | Merry Melffys (run 1 from extra only) / Gigantic Spright (flex slot) | Spright Smashers, Number 65: Djinn Buster, Sky Cavalry Centaurea, or Ronintoadin | Extra Deck slots should prioritize the meta Spright-Melffy toolbox. Merry Melffys and Gigantic Spright are secondary; the 100%-inclusion Spright cards provide more consistent summoning routes. |
| 4 | Alpha, the Master of Beasts (1 copy), Striker Dragon (1 copy) | Spright-focused support: Downerd Magician, Cat Shark, or The Phantom Knights of Cursed Javelin | Alpha and Striker Dragon are tech cards without synergy to Melffy or Spright lines. The meta Extra Deck lineup ensures better access to core Synchro/Xyz summoning. |
| 5 | No side deck | Construct a 15-card side deck with post-side transformational options | Deck currently has 0 side cards; a competitive side deck is essential for best-of-3 format adaptability. |
Evidence & confidence
- Verified: Legality status: Illegal (Obedience Schooled Forbidden, Maxx C 2 copies vs 1 legal, Called by Grave 2 copies vs 1 legal).; Main/Extra/Side counts: 40 main, 15 extra, 0 side.; Archetype purity: Melffy exact-name 14 copies, 25.5% of main deck.; Extra Deck breakdown: 3 Link, 5 Xyz, 7 Synchro.; Card text: All 50 unique cards resolved and cross-checked against role hints.; Usage statistics: 5/25 archetype core cards present (20%); 20/25 missing.
- Observed: Hand-trap inclusion: 9 copies (Ash 3, Infinite Impermanence 2, Maxx C 2, Nibiru 2).; Searcher count: 8 copies (Primite Lordly Lode 3, Primite Dragon Ether Beryl 3, Primite Drillbeam 2).; Melffy core distribution: Wally 3, Puppy 2, Pony 1, Catty 1, Fenny 1, Pinny 1, Rabby 1.
- Inferred: P(≥1 archetype core in opening hand 5) ≈ 0.64 from hypergeometric draw (7 viable starters / 40 deck).; Full brick rate (no archetype core in hand 5) ≈ 0.36.; Opening consistency D1 ≈ 42: weak core coverage offset by hand-trap density.; Combo ceiling and median: no boards supplied; inferred from card text (Synchro/Xyz summoning 2–3 monsters, 1–2 interactions per main turn).; Resilience D5 ≈ 40: Melffy effects trigger on opp summon but no independent alternate lines; recursion via Melffy Hide-and-Seek is single copy.; Going-second power ≈ 48: hand-trap density and Primite removal enable board disruption, but no guaranteed combo through multiple interactions.; Structural Deck Power ≈ 38 (before legality penalty): Midrange profile with reactive play pattern and moderate resource economy.
- Provisional: Meta Power: null — no dated metagame sample supplied; archetype meta-share and per-pilot tournament record absent.; Matchup coverage D13 ≈ 25: Melffy archetype historically mid-tier rogue; this build missing 80% of core engine cards cannot compete with legal meta lists.
- Data gaps: Legality violations prevent normal scoring: 3 Forbidden Obedience Schooled, 2 over-Limited Maxx C, 2 over-Limited Called by Grave. No combo boards supplied (combo data.scored combos = 0); all combo claims are text-only inference. No tournament link; archetype meta-share, per-pilot record, and metagame-specific performance data absent. No side deck (0 copies); post-side plan cannot be evaluated. No win-rate telemetry (going-first/second brick rate, OTK rate, matchup outcomes) supplied; all signals Inferred or Provisional. Meta Power Provisional: requires a dated competitive metagame sample to calibrate format fit and meta positioning.
Couldn't load the combos





