Magical Musket Deck #656169 — Yu-Gi-Oh! TCG

59 Main, 15 Extra, incl. Fiendsmith Engraver x3, Magical Musketeer Starfire x3, Mulcharmy Fuwalos x3.

Created by: YGO Mod (20517634)

Created On: 03/03/2026

 
 


Official AI Deck Power Analysis
ControlConfidence: MediumEvaluated Jul 9, 2026
38± 8/ 100
Power Score
Structural 60
Reliability 57
Going First 67
Going Second 60

Magical Musket (Illegal Build) — Deck Power Evaluation

Final Contextual Deck Power: 38/100 (±8 · Confidence: Medium)

Overall score Value
Structural Deck Power 60
Going First 67
Going Second 60
Meta Power provisional
Tournament Reliability 57
  • Primary strategy: Control
  • Secondary strategies: Combo, Trap-Centric
  • Format: tcg

Legality

Main 59 / Extra 15 / Side 0 — status under the rules at evaluation time: Illegal. 1 violation(s).

Identity & game plan

  • Win condition: Control opponent board with Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon negations and trap layer; grind via Mulcharmy draw engine and recursion; Generate pressure through Fiendsmith Fusion bosses (Rextremende, Desirae, Lacrima) while maintaining defensive negation setup
  • Turn 1 (going first): Open with Tract or Engraver to search LIGHT Fiend; build Fiendsmith Links (Requiem/Agnumday/Sequence); Fusion summon Lacrima or Rextremende; set negation traps (Dominus Purge, Impermanence, Last Stand)
  • Turn 2 (going second): Hand traps (Ash, Ghost Belle, Impermanence) disrupt; MST/Harpie's Feather Duster clear opponent Spell/Trap; push with Fiendsmith lines if hand permits
  • Recovery: Fiendsmith recursion via Engraver discard and Link GY effects; Radiant Typhoon recycling through Mandate; Mulcharmy draw engine if board established
  • After siding: Unable to assess — no side deck provided (0 cards)

Why it scores here

This deck is ILLEGAL in TCG format due to running 3 copies of Radiant Typhoon Chant, which is Limited to 1 copy only. The evaluation is structural and theoretical only and cannot serve as a playable deck score. Disregarding legality, the list exhibits coherent Control-Combo hybrid design: Fiendsmith and Radiant Typhoon engines enable consistent Fusion summons and negation-layered boards (D7: 72), with strong resilience through multiple independent starter types (D5: 68) and grind-oriented resource management (D6: 65). However, the oversized 59-card main deck significantly dilutes opening-hand quality (D2: 52) and consistency despite high searcher density (D1: 65), creating excessive brick risk. Going-second capabilities are medium (D8: 58) without dedicated board-clear effects. The final score of 38 reflects the Illegal status (base Structural 60 minus −22 illegality penalty) and cannot be submitted for sanctioned play.

Dimension scores

# Dimension Score Evidence
D1 Engine Accessibility & Consistency 65 P(≥1 searcher in opening 5) ≈ 0.85 from 18 cards with searcher-text roles; however, 59-card main deck dilutes this advantage compared to optimized 40-card builds (Inferred)
D2 Opening-Hand Quality & Brick Management 52 59-card main deck significantly increases brick rate; 13 triple-copy cards and 9 hand traps create redundancy/clogging risk; multiple conflicting Normal Summons (Starfire, Caspar, Swen all Level 3–4) reduce hand quality (Inferred)
D3 Combo Conversion & Ceiling 68 No combo boards supplied; inferred from card text: Fiendsmith enable Fusion summons to Rextremende (3000 ATK, unaffected) or Desirae (negates up to 3+ effects); Radiant Typhoon Varuroon creates board extension; ceiling estimated 2–3 boss monsters + negation layer (Inferred)
D4 Combo Floor & Median Output 55 No combo evidence provided; median output estimated lower than ceiling due to brick risk and hand-trap draw frequency; likely 1–2 negations + 1 Fiendsmith boss with limited graveyard materials (Inferred)
D5 Interruption Resilience & Route Redundancy 68 Multiple independent opener types (Magical Musket, Fiendsmith, Radiant Typhoon); Fiendsmith recovery via Engraver discard and Link monsters' GY effects; Radiant Typhoon recycling through Mandate; strong route redundancy (Inferred)
D6 Resource Economy, Recovery & Grind 65 Fiendsmith's Tract is +1 advantage (search then discard); Engraver/Lacrima provide GY recursion; Mulcharmy Fuwalos/Purulia enable draw engine if board established; Radiant Typhoon Mandate draws; resource-positive grind pattern (Inferred)
D7 End-Board & Interaction Quality 72 20 negation-text cards (Ash, Ghost Belle, Infinite Impermanence, Forbidden Droplet, etc.) + 20 removal-text cards; bosses Rextremende (unaffected except Fiendsmith), Desirae (negates), Lacrima (ATK reduction); Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon effects enable multiple negation layers; strong interaction density (Inferred)
D8 Going-Second & Board-Breaking Power 58 P(≥1 hand trap in opening 6 going-second) ≈ 0.6473; MST (3x), Harpie's Feather Duster (1x), Forbidden Droplet (3x), Called by the Grave (1x) enable Spell/Trap destruction; lacks heavy monster-removal suite for pure board-clear (Inferred)
D9 Offensive Pressure & Closing Power 45 Fiendsmith bosses cap at 3000 ATK (Rextremende) with no piercing; deck designed for control/grind not OTK; relies on board presence and effect disruption over damage output (Inferred)
D10 Main Deck Efficiency & Flexibility 48 59-card main deck (at legal max 60) over standard 40 reduces consistency; 31 distinct cards with 13 at 3x creates redundancy; archetype purity 14.9% (Magical Musket name only, 86% off-archetype splash) indicates high flexibility but poor compactness (Inferred)
D11 Extra Deck Efficiency & Coverage 72 15 extra deck slots filled with 15 distinct cards; 7 Links (Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon focus), 5 Fusions (Fiendsmith/generic), 3 XYZ (one-ofs); no wasted slots or garnets; strong coverage of Fiendsmith combo lines (Verified)
D12 Side Deck Adaptability 40 No side deck provided (0 cards submitted); best-of-3 adaptation cannot be assessed; post-side resilience unknown (Provisional)
D13 Matchup Coverage & Format Fit 50 No tournament context or archetype meta-share available; control positioning could counter certain meta or struggle depending on current format; assessment requires dated sample (Provisional)
D14 Pilotability & Error Tolerance 55 Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon chains require sequencing knowledge (8–12 steps typical T1); multiple decision points (Tract discard, targeting, column activation for Magical Musket); moderate-to-high complexity, not entry-level (Inferred)

How the score was computed

Strategy profile: 70% Control / 30% Combo. Structural ≈ 60, Going First ≈ 67, Going Second ≈ 60, Meta = provisional, Tournament Reliability ≈ 57. Modifiers: Illegality Penalty (-22); Oversized Deck Dilution (-3); Missing Side Deck (-2). Final formula: Illegal deck: base Structural (60) − Illegality modifier (−22 for Radiant Typhoon Chant over copy limit) = 38. Standard formula not applicable due to legal violation. Evaluation is theoretical/structural only and cannot be submitted for sanctioned play.

Probability & combo summary

  • Opening a starter: P(≥1) ≈ 0.85 · key two-card combo ≈ — · full-brick estimate ≈ 0.12 (all Inferred)
  • Combo output: best PowerIndex —, median —, board-per-starter —
  • Turn order: 0 going-first lines vs 0 going-second lines

Strengths

  • Multiple independent engine types (Magical Musket, Fiendsmith, Radiant Typhoon) provide strong redundancy and route flexibility
  • Excellent interaction layer through 20 negation-text and 20 removal-text cards; negation-heavy bosses (Rextremende unaffected except Fiendsmith, Desirae negates up to 3+)
  • Strong graveyard recursion (Fiendsmith's Engraver, Lacrima, Link monsters; Radiant Typhoon Mandate cycling) enables grindy, resource-positive game plans
  • High searcher density (P ≈ 0.85 for ≥1 in opening 5) and draw engine access (Mulcharmy, Mandate, Tract) support consistency
  • Fiendsmith Fusion Summon engine (Rextremende, Desirae, Lacrima) creates potent board presence with recursive material generation

Weaknesses

  • ILLEGAL: Runs 3 copies of Radiant Typhoon Chant (Limited card, 1 copy maximum) — deck is unplayable in sanctioned TCG format
  • Oversized 59-card main deck significantly dilutes consistency and increases brick rate despite high searcher density
  • Hand trap clutter (9 dedicated + 3 Ash + 3 Ghost Belle + 3 Impermanence) risks clogging hands early, reducing functional openers
  • Going-second board-breaking power limited; lacks dedicated mass-monster-removal (no Raigeki, heavy Fusion disruption)
  • Zero side deck (0 cards) eliminates best-of-3 adaptation potential and post-game resilience
  • Magical Musket column effects require Spell/Trap activation in same column; loss of board presence limits access to these synergies
  • Combo ceiling and floor entirely inferred from card text; no recorded boards prevent validation of actual line consistency

Critical choke points

  • Radiant Typhoon Chant illegality: This single card violation (3× vs 1×) makes the entire deck unplayable in sanctioned competition
  • Brick rate elevation: 59-card main with 13 triple-copy cards creates elevated risk of non-functional hands, especially with 9+ hand trap density
  • Fiendsmith recursion dependency: If Engraver is discarded early or Links are negated/removed, recovery slows significantly
  • Column activation requirement: Magical Musket effects require Spell/Trap activation in column; loss of board presence cuts off these synergies
  • No side deck: Inability to adjust post-game for specific matchups or counter strategies in best-of-3
Priority Remove Add Reason
1 Radiant Typhoon Chant (reduce from 3 to 1) One additional Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon support card or generic tech Deck is currently ILLEGAL. Reducing Radiant Typhoon Chant to 1 copy (Limited status) makes the deck legal for TCG play. Total: 57-card main. Also consider adding a missing tech card.
2 2–4 hand traps or redundant tech cards Land on 40–50 card main deck (optimized or conservative buffer) 59-card main dilutes consistency and raises brick rate. Reducing to 40–50 would improve opening-hand quality (D2) and engine accessibility (D1); oversizing outweighs flexibility gained.
3 Review hand trap density (currently 18 total discard-able negations) Optimize to 5–7 dedicated hand traps; retain core (3x Ash, 3x Impermanence, 1–2x Ghost Belle) Excessive hand trap density risks early-hand clogging. Consider cutting duplicate negation sources.
4 N/A Build and test 15-card side deck for best-of-3 formats No side deck currently exists (0 cards). Construct a side focused on common meta matchups (anti-combo cards, grind-breakers, interaction tech).
5 Constellar Ptolemy M7, Melomelody Brass Djinn, D/D/D Caesar (if not used) Verify extra deck slots or swap for additional Fiendsmith Links/Fusions if unused XYZ monsters appear unused given Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon focus. Confirm necessity or reallocate to archetype-coherent cards.

Evidence & confidence

  • Verified: Legality: ILLEGAL — Radiant Typhoon Chant 3× vs 1× legal (Verified); Card list fully resolved: All 59 main + 15 extra cards have correct text, attributes, banlist status; Deck composition: 31 distinct main, 15 distinct extra; copy histogram 1×16, 2×2, 3×13 (Verified); Archetype distribution: Magical Musket (11), Fiendsmith (15), Radiant Typhoon (10), Mulcharmy (6), generic (18) (Verified); Extra deck breakdown: 7 Links, 5 Fusions, 3 XYZ (Verified); Role tags: 9 hand trap, 17 tech, 20 negation-text, 20 removal-text (Verified)
  • Observed: Hypergeometric probability P(≥1 searcher in 5) ≈ 0.8503 from 18 searcher-text cards (Observed); Hypergeometric probability P(≥1 hand trap in 6 going-second) ≈ 0.6473 from 9 hand trap cards (Observed); Copy histogram frequency: 13 cards at 3×, 2 cards at 2×, 16 cards at 1× (Observed)
  • Inferred: D1: Engine consistency 65 — Searcher access high but 59-card dilution reduces practical opening rate (Inferred); D2: Brick management 52 — Estimated 12% full-brick from oversized deck and hand-trap clutter (Inferred); D3: Combo ceiling 68 — Fiendsmith Fusion enables 2–3 boss monsters + negation layer from card text (Inferred); D4: Combo floor 55 — Likely 1–2 negations + 1 boss with limited GY recursion on first turn (Inferred); D5: Resilience 68 — Multiple opener types + strong GY recursion redundancy support route flexibility (Inferred); D6: Resource economy 65 — Tract +1, Engraver recursion, Mulcharmy draw engine support grind pattern (Inferred); D7: Interaction quality 72 — 40 total negation+removal cards across hand traps and bosses; layering through multiple effects (Inferred); D8: Going-second 58 — Hand trap access 64.7%, S/T removal present but no mass-monster-clear (Inferred); D9: Closing power 45 — Bosses 3000 ATK max, no piercing, control-focused design (Inferred); D10: Main deck efficiency 48 — 59-card bloat, purity 14.9%, archetype-dispersed splash (Inferred); D11: Extra deck efficiency 72 — All 15 slots filled, Fiendsmith/Radiant Typhoon synergy high (Inferred); D12: Side adaptability 40 — Zero side cards; cannot assess best-of-3 adaptation (Inferred); D13: Matchup fit 50 — Control positioning unknown without dated meta; neutral estimate pending sample (Inferred); D14: Pilotability 55 — Fiendsmith/Radiant chains 8–12 steps, moderate-to-high complexity (Inferred)
  • Provisional: Meta Power: null — no dated metagame sample provided; archetype meta-share and per-pilot match record absent; Matchup coverage D13: Control strategy could be strong vs combo or weak vs grind depending on current format metagame; Post-side resilience: Cannot assess without side deck composition; best-of-3 performance unknown
  • Data gaps: No combo boards supplied — combo floor, median, ceiling derived from text-only inference rather than observed performance data No archetype usage statistics — cannot compare core card inclusion % vs standard Magical Musket lists or meta baseline No tournament link — archetype meta-share and per-pilot match records absent; meta power cannot be calculated No win-rate telemetry in YGOVN — going-first/second win rates, matchup results, brick/starter/OTK rates unknown No side deck supplied (0 cards) — best-of-3 adaptation and post-side performance cannot be assessed Deck is ILLEGAL (Radiant Typhoon Chant 3× vs 1×) — evaluation is theoretical only; cannot be submitted for sanctioned play until corrected

More TCG Info

Magical Musket

Magical Musket Breakdown

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

 
https://metaduelist.com/
Top