Umbral Horror Deck #474164 — Yu-Gi-Oh! OCG

40 Main, 15 Extra, incl. Astral Kuriboh x3, Kagetokage x3, Secret Sect Druid Dru x3.

Created by: YGO Mod (20517634)

Created On: 04/24/2025

 
 


Official AI Deck Power Analysis
ComboConfidence: LowEvaluated Apr 24, 2025
42± 8/ 100
Power Score
Structural 41
Reliability 38
Going First 48
Going Second 26

Deck — Deck Power Evaluation

Final Contextual Deck Power: 42/100 (±8 · Confidence: Low)

Overall score Value
Structural Deck Power 41
Going First 48
Going Second 26
Meta Power provisional
Tournament Reliability 38
  • Primary strategy: Combo
  • Secondary strategies: Xyz Toolbox
  • Format: ocg

Legality

Main 40 / Extra 15 / Side 0 — status: Legal.

Identity & game plan

  • Win condition: Rank-up Xyz summons into Number C104 or Super Starslayer for board negation and removal; Grind via Recurring Nightmare recursion and field control with Nightmare Throne
  • Turn 1 (going first): Summon Level 4 Xyz bosses (Number 104, Number 39) with negation/attack manipulation, rank up to Number C104 for removal and negation denial
  • Turn 2 (going second): Limited board-breaking options; rely on hand-trap synergy (absent) or grind through recursion with Recurring Nightmare
  • Recovery: Graveyard recursion via Recurring Nightmare (DARK 0 DEF monsters); extenders via Umbral Horror Ghoul and Will o' the Wisp conditional recursion
  • After siding: No sideboard present; structural post-side vulnerability

Why it scores here

This Umbral Horror Xyz deck struggles with consistency and execution. It aims to establish Rank-4 and Rank-5 Xyz monsters for interaction (negation via Number 104, removal via Number C104), but lacks the core starters (missing 100% of the archetype standard Mulcharmy Fuwalos) that competitive Umbral Horror decks run. Opening-hand quality is hampered by conflicting Level-4 Normal Summons (Summoner Monk, Secret Sect Druid Dru, Kagetokage fill similar slots), and the recursion engine via Recurring Nightmare alone is insufficient for recovery after disruption. The Extra Deck composition is overstuffed with generic high-Rank Xyz (AA-ZEUS, Super Starslayer) that lack reliable summoning conditions in this list. Going-second play is critically weak, with no dedicated board-breaker engine. No sideboard and zero hand-trap synergy compound these structural gaps; the deck's power comes from its Xyz interaction core, not from its engine coherence.

Dimension scores

# Dimension Score Evidence
D1 Engine Accessibility & Consistency 55 Ten 3-copy Level-4 starters (Summoner Monk, Ghoul, Druid Dru, Unform, Will o' the Wisp, Kagetokage) boost nominal draw odds, but redundancy and conflict (multiple Normal Summon gates competing for one summon) reduce effective consistency; P(≥1 usable starter in hand 5) estimated ~60% after conflict analysis (Inferred)
D2 Opening-Hand Quality & Brick Management 38 Three distinct Normal Summoned Level-4 monsters compete for one Normal Summon slot each turn; Astral Kuriboh is a live garnet if no Number Xyz is in Extra Deck hand; Kagetokage is a mandatory extender-only (Inferred); estimated full brick rate 15-18% (Inferred)
D3 Combo Conversion & Ceiling 48 Best recorded board from card text: Number 104 + Number C104 via rank-up, both with negation and removal effects; no parsed combos available, text-only ceiling estimated ~PowerIndex 58-62 (Inferred)
D4 Combo Floor & Median Output 42 Median expected board: single Rank-4 Xyz (Number 39 or 104) with one negate effect and modest ATK; rank-up to C104 inconsistent without guaranteed searchers; median PowerIndex estimated 42-48 (Inferred)
D5 Interruption Resilience & Route Redundancy 35 Single dedicated disruption route (Xyz summon into Number 104 negate); one choke point (Level 4 Normal Summon); recovery via Recurring Nightmare requires 2+ DARK 0 DEF monsters in GY, unreliable early-turn; independent lines minimal; estimated resilience score 35 (Inferred)
D6 Resource Economy, Recovery & Grind 52 Barian's Chaos Draw and Seventh Ascension provide card advantage; Recurring Nightmare recycles DARK 0 DEF but requires setup; net resource outflow in early turns; grind potential moderate but slow (Inferred)
D7 End-Board & Interaction Quality 50 Number 104 negates opponent monster effects during battle phase (1 effect negate per material); Number C104 provides spell/trap removal on summon; Raider's Knight enables rank-shifting; interaction density moderate but not layered; estimated quality ~50 (Inferred)
D8 Going-Second & Board-Breaking Power 28 No dedicated going-second removal suite (no board breaker archetype support); relies on Number 104 effect negation during battle, which is passive; Evilswarm Nightmare changes position (tempo only); critical weakness; estimated power 28 (Inferred)
D9 Offensive Pressure & Closing Power 35 Number 104 max ATK 2700, Number C104 max ATK 3000, Arc Rebellion 3000 ATK; piercing damage absent; closing power requires multiple turns of battle; no OTK line; estimated 35 (Inferred)
D10 Main Deck Efficiency & Flexibility 42 40-card main with 17 distinct cards; 10 copies devoted to conflicting Level-4 starters (efficiency loss); 12 searcher-type cards (Seventh Ascension, Barian's Chaos Draw, Recurring Nightmare, Seventh Tachyon) compete for activation slots; redundancy burden moderate; estimated 42 (Inferred)
D11 Extra Deck Efficiency & Coverage 55 All 15 Extra Deck slots are Xyz monsters; 12 distinct (2 copies Number 104/C104, 2 Super Starslayer, rest 1-of); high Rank slots (AA-ZEUS Rank 12, Starslayer Rank 12) have no reliable access from this list; many flex slots; estimated efficiency 55 (Inferred)
D12 Side Deck Adaptability 0 No sideboard provided; zero post-side adaptability; critical gap; scored 0 per schema (Verified)
D13 Matchup Coverage & Format Fit 30 Archetype meta-share unknown (no tournament context); deck runs 0 core cards from the 5 standard Umbral Horror staples (Mulcharmy Fuwalos 100%, Ash Blossom 50%, Number 104 50%, C104 50%, Droll & Lock Bird 50%); format fit unverified; estimated 30 (Provisional)
D14 Pilotability & Error Tolerance 40 Combo route is straightforward (Normal Summon → Xyz Summon → Rank-Up); few decision points; but Barian's Chaos Draw is draw-phase-dependent (hard to pilot around); Seventh Tachyon requires Deck reveal; moderate complexity; estimated tolerance 40 (Inferred)

How the score was computed

Strategy profile: Combo. Structural ≈ 41, Going First ≈ 48, Going Second ≈ 26, Meta = provisional, Tournament Reliability ≈ 38. Modifiers: zero_core_cards (-8); no_sideboard (-3); weak_going_second (-2). Final formula: 0.80*Structural(41) + 0.20*TournamentReliability(38) (Meta provisional)

Probability & combo summary

  • Opening a starter: P(≥1) ≈ — · key two-card combo ≈ — · full-brick estimate ≈ 0.15 (all Inferred)
  • Combo output: best PowerIndex —, median —, board-per-starter —
  • Turn order: 0 going-first lines vs 0 going-second lines

Strengths

  • Xyz negation framework: Number 104 and Number C104 provide multi-layered interaction (negation denial, spell/trap removal)
  • Flexible searcher suite: Seventh Ascension, Barian's Chaos Draw, and Recurring Nightmare offer multiple paths to engine pieces
  • High Extra Deck density: 15 Xyz slots provide rank-shifting flexibility and toolbox coverage (Evilswarm Nightmare, Raider's Knight, Utopia variants)
  • Graveyard recursion loop: Recurring Nightmare recycles DARK 0 DEF monsters for extended plays

Weaknesses

  • Critical core deficiency: runs 0 of Mulcharmy Fuwalos (100% inclusion standard), Ash Blossom, Number 104/C104, Droll & Lock Bird; missing foundational engine pieces
  • Severe going-second weakness: no dedicated board-breaker engine; passive Xyz negation insufficient for meta removal threats
  • Starter redundancy and conflicts: ten competing Level-4 Normal Summons (Summoner Monk, Druid Dru, Kagetokage, others) reduce effective consistency; no conflict resolution
  • No sideboard: zero post-side adaptability in best-of-3 format
  • Choke-point vulnerability: single Normal Summon gate; loss of starter = loss of turn-1 board
  • Garnet risk: Astral Kuriboh locks Extra Deck to Number Xyz only; situationally dead
  • Inconsistent rank-up access: Rank-Up-Magic pieces (3 total) insufficient for reliable turn-1 C104 summon; secondary effect (draw-phase dependency in Barian's Chaos Draw) unreliable

Critical choke points

  • Level 4 Normal Summon: deck pivots entirely on this single summon; no alternative acceleration engines (no Fusion/Synchro routes, no Pendulum scale, no Link)
  • Recurring Nightmare setup: requires 2+ DARK 0 DEF monsters already in GY; useless early game; slow recursion
  • Barian's Chaos Draw draw-phase dependency: requires draw-phase reveal; cannot force activation; dead if drawn in MP1
  • Rank-Up-Magic access: only 3 rank-up spells for ~5 turn-1 Xyz summons; late-hand RUM = failed rank-up turn
  • Astral Kuriboh lock: reveals Number Xyz, locks Extra Deck; if the revealed monster is removed, Kuriboh becomes a brick
Priority Remove Add Reason
1 All 10 copies of conflicting Level-4 Normal Summons (reduce Summoner Monk, Druid Dru, Kagetokage, Unform to 1 copy each); cut 6-7 copies total 3x Mulcharmy Fuwalos (100% standard); 2x Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring; 1-2x hand-trap staples (Droll & Lock Bird, Ghost Ogre & Snow Rabbit, or format equivalents) Deck currently has zero core cards; adding the archetype standard and hand-trap coverage is essential for consistency and going-second resistance
2 Astral Kuriboh (3x) — the Level-change + Extra Deck lock is too restrictive and creates garnet risk 3x Rank-Up-Magic (consolidate to a reliable suite: Barian's Force 2x + The Seventh One 1x, or substitute with Rank-Up-Magic Astral Force if in-format); or 2x additional searchers (Sacred Beasts Opening of the Spirit Gates is present but underutilized) Astral Kuriboh lock reduces flexibility and the core RUM count (3 total) is insufficient for consistent rank-up access
3 Opening of the Spirit Gates (2x), Nightmare Throne (2x) — these are Sacred Beast and Yubel tech, not Umbral Horror engine pieces Fill with 1-2x board-breaker support (e.g. if format allows: Red-Eyes Fusion, Super Polymerization, or dedicated going-second removal staples); prepare sideboard (15 slots) for post-side transition Tech slots dilute deck identity and going-second plan; sideboard is critical for best-of-3 competitiveness
4 Don Thousand's Throne (1x), Seventh Tachyon (1x) — niche draw triggers and inconsistent activation 2x additional Rank-4 Xyz access or 1x Number C102: Archfiend Seraph for Rank-up ceiling expansion Don Thousand's Throne is strictly better as a side-deck tech; Seventh Tachyon's draw-phase reveal gate is unreliable
5 Leave as-is or reduce by 1: Barian's Chaos Draw (3x) — only 1-2 are reliably activatable per game Build full 15-card sideboard with: 2-3 anti-meta floodgates (Macro Cosmos, Dimensional Fissure if 0 ATK/DEF recursion meta), 2-3 going-second board-breaker suites (Forbidden Chalice, Effect Veiler, or equivalents), 3x hand-trap flex Sideboard presence is mandatory for format competitiveness; current list is uncut and inflexible

Evidence & confidence

  • Verified: Legality: 40 Main / 15 Extra / 0 Side (OCG rules met; Terraforming Limited 1x legal); Card text per evidence.json description excerpts (all 29 unique cards resolved); Extra Deck composition: 15 Xyz monsters, 0 Fusion/Synchro/Link; Usage statistics: Mulcharmy Fuwalos 100% inclusion, Ash Blossom/Number 104/C104/Droll & Lock Bird 50% — all missing from this deck; No sideboard present (0/15 slots)
  • Observed: Archetype purity: 11 exact-name Umbral Horror cards out of 55 total (20%); Barian's/Seventh/Utopia/Sacred Beast sub-archetype spread indicates toolbox drift; Copy histogram: 4 singles, 3 doubles, 10 triples (heavy 3-copy concentration); 10 triples are Level-4 Normal Summon bodies
  • Inferred: Consistency: P(≥1 usable Level-4 starter in hand 5) estimated 0.60 after conflict analysis (10 competing bodies); nominal hypergeometric ≈0.85, but Normal Summon slot bottleneck reduces effective probability; Opening-hand brick rate: ~15-18% (Astral Kuriboh garnet + conflicting Normal Summons + Rank-Up-Magic whiffs); Combo ceiling: Rank-4 Xyz → Rank-Up to C104; dual negate/removal PowerIndex estimated 58-62 (no parsed boards; text-only inference); Combo median: single Rank-4 negate board; PowerIndex estimated 42-48 (secondary rank-up inconsistent without guaranteed searcher in hand); Going-second power: passive negation via Number 104 during opponent battle phase; no dedicated board-breaker line; estimated floor 26-28 (Inferred); Resilience: single Normal Summon choke point; recovery via Recurring Nightmare requires GY setup; independent lines minimal; estimated 35 (Inferred); Extra Deck slot efficiency: 7 slots underutilized (AA-ZEUS, Starslayer Rank 12 — no reliable summon path; Utopia variants situational); redundancy in Rank-4 toolbox
  • Provisional: Meta Power: null — no dated metagame sample provided; archetype meta-share unknown; format fit Provisional until tournament representation data supplied; Matchup viability: Umbral Horror representation status in OCG unknown; this list's deviation from core suggests non-meta or casual build; Post-side power: zero sideboard makes best-of-3 evaluation theoretical; estimated post-side plan power Provisional until sideboard supplied
  • Data gaps: No combo boards parsed: combo floor, median, ceiling are text-only inferences; best-line and board-per-starter unknown No tournament context: archetype meta-share, pilot match records, format representation all absent; format fit unverified No sideboard provided: 0/15 slots; post-side adaptability unevaluable; critical gap for best-of-3 scoring No win-rate telemetry: brick rates, starter success rates, going-first vs going-second winrate, matchup records all absent from YGOVN Guides absent: no strategic intent documentation; archetype standard ratios inferred from usage stats only Usage-stat core mismatch: deck runs 0/5 core cards (Mulcharmy Fuwalos mandatory); reason for deviation unknown (budget? format restriction? experimental?)

More OCG Info

Umbral Horror

Umbral Horror Breakdown

 
 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

 
https://metaduelist.com/
Top