Wightmare
DARK 1

Wightmare

  • Archetype:
  • Skull Servant

  • ATK:
  • 300

  • DEF:
  • 200

  • View:
  • 4519




This card's name becomes "Skull Servant" while in the GY. You can discard this card, then activate 1 of the following effects. ● Target 1 of your banished "Skull Servant" or "Wightmare"; return it to the GY. ● Target 1 of your banished "The Lady in Wight" or "King of the Skull Servants"; Special Summon it.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
Recovery/RecursionConfidence: MediumEvaluated Oct 7, 2026
54± 8/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 52
Deck 56

Wightmare — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 54 ± 8 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 52 · Deck: 56 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Recovery/Recursion · Secondary: Extender

Why it scores here

Wightmare's text converts its own discard into a banish-zone recursion: it returns a banished Skull Servant or Wightmare to the GY, or Special Summons a banished The Lady in Wight or King of the Skull Servants. That is a real but narrow conversion, and it depends on banished targets that the text does not guarantee. It is in all 399 sampled decks, but that near-universal presence reflects its archetype home (Skull Servant) and does not by itself earn power, so the score rests on the text and the thin combo data. Its level-1 body, lack of interaction and archetype-locked text keep it in the middle band.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 72 Present in 399 of 399 sampled decks at about 2 copies on average, and the text makes it a discard-cost card that is probably live from hand (inferred; no combo starter data supports it) (observed/inferred).
Combo & Conversion 45 No recorded boards exist (total combos 0), so the conversion rests on the two text effects and the King of the Skull Servants and Lady in Wight banish targets (inferred).
Resource Economy 55 Discarding itself costs one card, but the Special Summon of a banished monster returns a body, so the exchange is roughly even with a small gain; nothing refuels the hand (inferred from text).
Effect & Interaction 10 The text has no negation, removal or hand-trap effect, so interaction is essentially absent (verified).
Material Utility 30 A Level 1 DARK Zombie is a clean generic material in principle, but no material usage was recorded and the body's text is archetype-specific (inferred; material role 0).
Resilience & Flexibility 55 The GY name change and two banish-zone targets give it more than one live spot, but both effects need banished targets and nothing protects it from banish-zone hate (inferred from text).
Deck-Building Efficiency 70 Two to three copies typical with no garnet or lock restriction, though it is tied to the Skull Servant archetype (observed/inferred).

Calculation

Weight profile: 0.7 Recovery/Recursion + 0.3 Extender. Intrinsic ≈ 52, Deck ≈ 56, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Live in 399 of 399 sampled decks, so access is not the bottleneck
  • Cheap to run: two to three copies, no garnet or lock cost
  • Two text effects give it more than one target in the banish zone and the GY

Weaknesses

  • No interaction at all: no negation, removal or hand trap
  • Both effects need banished targets, so they can go dead when the banish zone is empty
  • Recorded combo evidence is absent, so conversion value is text-only
  • Archetype-locked text limits portability across homes

Counters / choke points

  • Graveyard or banish hate is not in the evidence, but anything that removes banished targets would blank both effects (inferred)

Best use

Recursion and banish-zone revival in a Skull Servant engine. Decks: Skull Servant (archetype 652), Skull Servant (archetype 380). Suggested copies: 2.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Two effects: return a banished Skull Servant or Wightmare to the GY; Special Summon a banished The Lady in Wight or King of the Skull Servants; The name becomes Skull Servant while in the GY; Level 1 DARK Zombie, 300 ATK / 200 DEF
  • Observed: In 399 of 399 sampled decks; 2.01 copies on average; King of the Skull Servants and Wightprince are present in nearly all decks; Archetype inclusion 50% with 2 typical copies (Skull Servant, 380)
  • Inferred: The discard cost is taken from hand, since the text gives no location; Its banish-zone effects can go dead without banished targets; Net card economy is roughly even
  • Data gaps: no combos supplied, so combo conversion is text-only inference no guides supplied no banlist token, so 3 copies assumed (unlimited) activation location and once-per-turn wording are not stated in the text provided











https://metaduelist.com/
Top