Trap
CounterSolemn Judgment
Archetype:
Solemn
View:
3985
When a monster(s) would be Summoned, OR a Spell/Trap Card is activated: Pay half your LP; negate the Summon or activation, and if you do, destroy that card.
Solemn Judgment — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 63 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 66.3 · Deck: 63.5 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Negation/Interaction
Why it scores here
Solemn Judgment converts one set Trap slot into the broadest single-card negation in the game: at Counter Trap Speed 3 it negates any monster Summon or any Spell/Trap activation and destroys the card, which is why 400 of 400 sampled decks main-deck it across 128 distinct archetypes. It earns nothing for ATK/DEF (it has none) or for popularity; its ceiling is set by real costs — it must be set and survive a turn, pays half your LP, is Limited to 1 in TCG/OCG/Master Duel and is unsearchable in the sampled builds, making it a draw-dependent one-of. Combo data confirms it builds nothing (0% as starter, searched, material or payoff), so essentially all of its weighted value sits in effect_interaction.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 58 | Unsearchable in the sampled builds and Limited to 1 in TCG/OCG/Master Duel, so it is a draw-dependent one-of that also has to be set for a turn before it becomes live (inferred). |
| Combo & Conversion | 17 | Across the 9 recorded combos it appears in, it is 0% starter role, 0% searched-for role, 0% material role and 0% payoff role, so it constructs nothing on its own (observed). |
| Resource Economy | 45 | The text trades at best 1-for-1 (negate plus destroy against the Trap itself) while paying half your LP, so it never generates card advantage (verified). |
| Effect & Interaction | 90 | The text negates any monster Summon OR any Spell/Trap activation and destroys that card, at Speed 3 that monster effects and Speed 2 Spell/Traps cannot chain to (verified). |
| Material Utility | 0 | As a Counter Trap it supplies no body, Level, Attribute or archetype name value and cannot be used as material (verified). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 52 | It is a one-shot that must be set and survive the opponent's turn and becomes risky or dead at low LP, although its trigger covers any Summon or Spell/Trap activation (inferred). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 75 | One slot, no archetype lock, no garnet and no self-locking restriction — 400/400 sampled decks main-deck it at 1.04 copies on average, though the Limited-to-1 status blocks any redundancy (observed). |
Calculation
Weight profile: pure Removal / Negation profile (no meaningful secondary role). Intrinsic ≈ 66.3, Deck ≈ 63.5, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: Limited to 1 in TCG/OCG/Master Duel (-4); Exceptional splashability (2). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Negates any monster Summon as well as any Spell/Trap activation, one of the widest single-card negation windows in the game.
- Counter Trap Speed 3: monster effects and normal Spell/Trap Speed 2 responses cannot chain to it.
- Also destroys the negated card, so the stop is permanent rather than temporary.
- Completely generic — no archetype lock, no cost other than LP, fits any deck with Trap space (128 distinct archetypes observed).
- Includes inherent Special Summons, so it stops a boss before it ever reaches the field.
Weaknesses
- Must be set and survive a turn before use; it is not a hand trap and is exposed to backrow removal during that window.
- Paying half your LP is a large, escalating cost and can be unusable or suicidal at low LP.
- Limited to 1 in TCG/OCG/Master Duel and unsearchable in the sampled builds, so it is a draw-dependent one-of.
- Builds nothing: 0% starter role, searched-for role, material role and payoff role in the recorded combos.
- Provides no board presence, material or name/Level/Attribute value of its own.
Counters / choke points
- Backrow removal played before the set turn resolves (e.g. Harpie's Feather Duster, Lightning Storm, Cosmic Cyclone — all observed as partners/popular cards).
- Counter Traps that negate its activation (e.g. a second Solemn Judgment, or Trap-negating Counter Traps).
- Traps that cannot be ignored: Red Reboot-style Trap shutdown effects.
- LP pressure strategies that push the user below a safe half-LP payment.
Best use
Generic one-of Counter Trap used to negate a key Summon or a decisive Spell/Trap activation. Decks: Branded, Sky Striker, Fiendsmith, Bystial/Byssted, Control and stun variants. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: 'When a monster(s) would be Summoned, OR a Spell/Trap Card is activated: Pay half your LP; negate the Summon or activation, and if you do, destroy that card.'; Frame is Trap, race Counter — Speed 3 counter trap.; legal copies is 1 in TCG, OCG and Master Duel.; Archetype tag is 'Solemn'.
- Observed: 400/400 sampled decks run it in the main deck; 0 in the side; average 1.04 copies (390 decks at 1 copy).; Appears in 128 distinct archetypes; top co-deck partners are Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring (94.2%), Droll & Lock Bird (91.5%) and Mulcharmy Fuwalos (83%).; Appears in 9/9 recorded combos but with 0% starter role, searched-for role, material role, payoff role and end-board appearances — it is present in decks, not in the lines.; Average structural power index when present is 73, with average starter count when present 3.11.; top-card data: rank 9 in TCG (avg 85.4%) and rank 16 in OCG (avg 81.9%).; usage statistics: 100% inclusion at 1 copy across 25 listed archetypes (saturated — treated as confirmation of adoption, not power).
- Inferred: Not searchable in the sampled builds, so access depends on drawing the single Limited copy and setting it for a turn.; Because it is a set Trap, backrow removal resolving before its use pre-empts it entirely.; The half-LP cost makes it progressively worse at low LP and awkward in LP-sensitive builds.; Its trigger window applies to Summons and Spell/Trap activations only — it cannot stop Graveyard effects, discards, or already-resolved effects.
- Data gaps: combo data records no combo role for this card (all starter role/material role/payoff role/end-board counts are 0), so combo centrality could not be measured and the 100% appearance figure only shows deck co-membership. No dated metagame sample is supplied in this pipeline, so meta power is left null/provisional. usage statistics inclusion percentages are saturated (100% across all 25 archetypes), so they cannot differentiate power and were used only as adoption confirmation. No evidence of archetype-specific search routes (e.g. Trap searchers) in the sampled decks.






